BUDGET YOUR TIME WISELY. These take an hour to cook after prep! Keep that in mind if you’re hankering for starchy goodness these cold winter months.
You’ll need:
- 4-6 large, starchy potatoes (gold or russet are best), all similar size
- oil (olive oil adds nice flavor, but plain old vegetable oil is fine)
- salt
- Foil
- Tongs
- A baking sheet (optional)
- An oven set to 425 degrees F
- A fork
Set out your foil. If you’re using a baking sheet, put it on the sheet. (You can place potatoes on the oven rack- the sheet just makes things more convenient.) For crispy skin, bake with the potatoes unwrapped. For softer skin, wrap them individually in foil. The ones above were unwrapped.
Scrub your potatoes and remove any blemishes. Poke them all over with a fork. Dry your potatoes and then rub them all over with oil. Side note: olive oil is good for the skin in dry winter conditions- a good reason to just get in there and use your hands. You can’t wash off oil very well, though- use a paper towel or napkin to wipe off the extra.
Sprinkle on some salt. If you’re wrapping your potatoes, do that now.
Bake in the oven for 50-60 minutes. Turn over after 20 minutes, after 40, and then check them at 50. If a fork slides right through when you poke one, it’s done. If not, put them in for another 5-10 minutes.
Serve with whatever toppings you like on your potatoes. Butter, sour cream, french onion dip, cheese soup, Cincinnati chili, shredded cheese, bacon.. whatever floats your boat!